B. Central hypothyroidism with an inappropriately normal TSH despite a low free T4
Why this is correct
In central hypothyroidism due to pituitary or hypothalamic disease, TSH secretion or bioactivity is inadequate for the prevailing low circulating T4. TSH may be low, apparently normal, or occasionally slightly elevated but biologically less active; therefore TSH alone cannot exclude central hypothyroidism. Replacement is generally monitored using free T4 and clinical status rather than attempting to normalize TSH. When multiple pituitary deficits are possible, adrenal insufficiency should be assessed and treated first as appropriate to avoid precipitating adrenal crisis with thyroid hormone replacement.
Why each option is correct or incorrect
Primary hypothyroidism classically causes a compensatory increase in TSH, which is absent relative to the low T4 here.
Correct: the normal-range TSH is physiologically inappropriate in central hypothyroidism.
Subclinical hyperthyroidism implies suppressed TSH with normal free thyroid hormones, not low free T4.
Graves usually raises thyroid hormone with suppressed TSH; the postpituitary surgery context points elsewhere.
High-yield notes
- Central hypothyroidism: low free T4 with low or inappropriately normal TSH.
- TSH is unreliable for adjusting replacement in central hypothyroidism.
- Evaluate cortisol deficiency before starting thyroid hormone when hypopituitarism is suspected.
A normal TSH does not rule out hypothyroidism after pituitary damage.
Starting levothyroxine without evaluating concurrent adrenal insufficiency may trigger adrenal crisis.