D. Mechanical swinging of the heart within a fluid-filled pericardial sac
Why this is correct
Electrical alternans refers to beat-to-beat variation in QRS amplitude or axis, classically seen when a large pericardial effusion permits the heart to swing within the sac. The changing position of the heart relative to surface electrodes produces alternating complexes. Although suggestive of a large effusion, this finding is neither required nor sufficient to diagnose tamponade; echocardiography and hemodynamics guide that assessment.
Why each option is correct or incorrect
Changes in pacemaker site are not the typical cause of classic electrical alternans in an effusion.
Cardiac muscle does not cyclically disappear between beats.
A moving coronary thrombus does not account for the characteristic alternating surface voltage.
Correct: movement of the heart in pericardial fluid alters the recorded electrical axis/amplitude.
High-yield notes
- Large effusion may cause low voltage and electrical alternans.
- Tamponade is primarily a hemodynamic diagnosis.
- Echo may show right-sided chamber collapse and plethoric IVC in tamponade.
Electrical alternans is a classic but insensitive clue to a large pericardial effusion.
Do not diagnose tamponade from ECG alternans alone; assess blood pressure, JVP and echo findings.